I mentioned before that I had a few points I wanted to make with respect to the physical external
adab of the Qur'an, physical
adab in terms of internally with the Qur'an and then propose some solutions and ideas on how to memorise more of this Mighty and Final Testament.
I don't wish to touch on those issues which are already well known, or agreed upon between the scholars, but rather those more specific issues that are discussed these days or are unique to our situation in the 21st Century today.
Anyway, here is the first installment. It's long and there's no pictures and the screen is black and the writing is painfully white. So it might not be too much fun. But it never was meant to be either. Yeah.
Expect the second in a few weeks or so insha'Allah.
The Qur’ān and Us – Part IOne of the results of living in our post-modern societies in the West is our increased cynicism with all that which is classical, holy, blessed, miraculous, supernatural etc. This has been a direct side-effect from growing up and living in a community which is purely secular in nature, where God has no significance, and where anything that can not be directly observed and proved is immediately rubbished. Call it the Age of Empiricism or call it the Age of Ignorance, what can not be doubted is how it has affected the mindset of millions of Muslims in the “developed” world, and worse even, now starting to play its way down into the Muslim (often synonymous with the) “developing” world.
It’s unfortunate that many Muslims hesitate to act freely in certain issues, afraid that others surrounding them might consider such actions or beliefs as backward or strange. Hence for example, we find some Muslims whilst still having an internal theoretical faith in the subject, are unwilling to express their belief in the supernatural or as the Qur’ān describes it,
al-‘Ālam’l-Ghayb or the “Unseen Realm”.
Consequently, we find great difficulty in having a serious discussion about Angels or the Jinn. We find it complicated to talk about
al-Hajr’l-Aswad (the Black Stone) or
al-Rukn al-Yamāni (the Yemeni Corner of the
Ka‘bah) etc. Likewise, to freely extol the blessings of a certain act, or a certain day or a certain night such as
Laylat’l-Qadr becomes strained, especially if questioned on the rationale or logic. Naturally, the Believer recognises the basis of such belief in the Unseen and is strong upon that but yet must still recognise the threat. If the prevailing environment still hasn’t shaken the
internal belief, it seems apparent from ones observations that the frequency and intensity of religious devotional practice of the
external is very much in danger.
Add to this the incredibly fast-paced way we live our lives with the further problem of materialism and secularist ideology insisting that religion be practised and expressed on the “down-low” and then we can recognise a real problem facing our Muslims today.
Couple this modern problem with the ever-existent
ikhtilāf or difference of opinion that exists amongst scholars with respect to certain spiritual acts and rituals and one might not be blamed for believing that deep spirituality and emotions such as esteem and sanctity are under attack.
As this section is dealing with the Qur’ān, one can observe specific problems of a similar nature with respect to our direct relationship with the Holy Book.
It is a sad fact that people are not reflecting and benefiting from this great gift to humanity: a deep spiritual message and yet expansive code of conduct for life itself. It is a shame that so many people, whilst recognising its internal beauty and melody, its healing power and the way it invokes ones strongest emotions and yet logically clarifies ones senses, still find difficulty in connecting to this holiest and most sanctified of words – indeed the words of our Creator, Allah, the Mighty and Exalted.
Maybe one of the starting points to re-establishing our relationship with the Qur’ān is to recognise its status and thereby allow it to gain our utter respect and reverence. Hence,
adab with the Qur’ān is a vital beginning point.
Rediscovering our Adab
The Muslim recognises from the very fundamental precept of faith that the Qur’ān is not just some created book but actually the
real spoken words of Allah
‘azza wa jall Himself, gifted to mankind as a
whole yet directed to
us specifically as individuals. If one was to internalise this fact for the briefest of moments, its sheer profoundness manifests itself.
This is enough to shake the Believer to his core when dealing with the Qur’ān. Hence, all such scenarios that involve disrespect to the Qur’ān in any way possible such as to intentionally throw it, step on it, tear it up, deny its rulings etc are tantamount to disbelief. Likewise, the Islamic rulings concerning the obligation of purity before the Qur’ān such as being in a state of ablution or free from sexual and menstrual impurity are well known and indeed ‘religiously’ followed.
Indeed, many scholars of the Qur’ān have advocated going much further and established a recommended code of conduct with the Qur’ān in order for Believers to further express their awe in which they view the Words of Allah, with the hope that such sanctification and wonder will further increase the effect of the Qur’ān upon their respective beliefs and actions. Hence, albeit without much technical evidence from the Prophetic period, scholars recommended Muslims that before they read the Qur’ān to perfume themselves, to wear pure and clean clothes, to face the Qiblah, to ensure sufficient previous rest and many other points.
Yet some scholars throughout history have argued that such recommendations cannot be justified without Prophetic sanctioning and also put the case forward that such ‘codes of conduct’, albeit for the sake of argument only ‘recommended’ and hence voluntary, were actually acting as barriers for millions of Muslims who just wanted to discover and reflect upon the true meanings of His Words, at all times and places, at every single opportunity. And still the debate goes on.
It is in the opinion of this author that there does not need to be a contradiction between both approaches. It is of no doubt that the most important relationship and indeed
obligation with the Qur’ān is for its followers to
act upon it and not to read it or venerate it in a physical sense.
Yet, especially in the age that we live in where Muslims are losing touching with the physical sanctity of the Qur’ān as previously mentioned alongside the growing “progressive” lobby which increasingly views such “ritualistic actions of insignificance” as defunct, there is a real need for Muslims to get back into an intense
adab relationship with the physical Qur’ān itself whilst at the same time recognising that to concentrate on reflecting upon its spiritual depths at the same time is the key objective.
Scholars have always suggested in their classical texts a possible approach to increasing
adab with a person – such as explaining how one should present themselves in their daily prayers in front of Allah
‘azza wa jall as one would do if presenting themselves to the King of the land but of course recognising the infinitely greater and more perfect nature of the Creator of the Universe. Using such examples with the Qur’ān itself are not out of place - treating the Qur’ān like a very precious object such as a priceless diamond can help focus the Believer on its sanctity and help us on the way to further our relationship with the Qur’ān.
Hence to keep the Qur’ān in a high position, to keep the Qur’ān on top of other books and never below other books, to never rest anything upon the Qur’ān be it paper, or pens or even using it as a pillow as mentioned in the books of
fiqh – simply treating the Book as if it were something else very rarely helps us to internalise the importance.
Likewise to read the Qur’ān sitting in an upright position and facing the
Qiblah, to not point our feet towards the Qur’ān or even intentionally turn our back to it; such recommendations have been gleaned from the later generations of the Companions and
Salaf or the early founding fathers of Islam.
Unsurprisingly, without actual legal evidence, certain scholars were more prudent in their advising of Muslims to enter in to such practices fearing that they would be seen as necessary parts of religious practice and hence become blameworthy innovations.
Of course, the various suggested points of
adab have only been religious advice and much of it simply subjective opinion of what respect actually is. What might be seen as disrespectful to one group of people could be seen as totally normal to another culture and so on. Take the case of pointing the feet towards a copy of the Qur’ān upon its holder. Some said that there was not a single piece of evidence to suggest this was blameworthy. The reply of course was that there are many cultures that hold it incredibly disrespectful to sit in front of them with their feet pointing towards them. It just wouldn’t be done. So how can one not do an action out of fear of offence to a normal person and yet do it so lackadaisically to the Book of Allah?
Here, certain
Usūli scholars mentioned a principle concerning the Qur’ān which this author feels would be applicable for our study:
“Every action that has not been prohibited by the
Sharī‘ah and is intended to make
takrīm and
ta‘dhīm (honour and veneration) of the Mus-haf (a written copy of the Qur’ān), then this is good and acceptable. This is because all actions which are permissible in principle, when used to arrive at something legislated, become ‘legislated’ themselves in that specific restricted sense as long as the person does not belief as a result of this that said action is recommended (
Sunnah) by itself or necessarily required – this is out of fear that something be added to the religion of Islam that which is not from it. ” (1)
The support for honouring the Qur’ān as such comes from the statement of Allah,
“As for those who honour Allah’s sacred rites, that comes from the taqwa in their hearts.” (al-Hajj, 32) which is general in all that which Allah has shown and taught his servants with respect to the religion. A general evidence is really all that is required here since the
Mus-haf as we have today wasn’t really around at the time of the Prophet (
sallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam); thus, any permissible action used in relation to the Qur’ān out of respect and honour is considered permissible except that this often leaves the door open to people exaggerating and going to extremes in their behaviour. Therefore, it is necessary to have some sort of guidelines to reign in peoples’ subjectivity in this issue and those guidelines are seen to be the actions of the Companions and their Successors (
Sahābah and
Tābi‘īn). Note that these generations are not being used in a legislative sense, rather simply as a standard to avoid any mistakes and exaggeration since they were the closest of all people in history to the Qur’ān and most in awe and respect of it.
Using this principle helps us to achieve that balance one feels is required in our times, avoiding fallacious concepts such as standing for the Qur’ān when it is brought into the room or walking out of a room backwards that contains a Qur’ān in it, yet protecting age-old practices of
‘urf (culture) that our elders and predecessors have used to maintain their love of the Qur’ān.
However despite this principle, other points of
adab still remain contentious with scholars who were either critical of the above principle in their attempt to safeguard the pure religion or they were in doubt over the existence of early generational ‘support’ for such actions such as the kissing of the Qur’ān, even though it is seen as a perfectly natural way of expressing love and respect for something which is incredibly precious and dear to the hearts.
This action has been established on the authority of the Companion ‘Ikrimah b. Abi Jahl (
radhy Allāhu ‘anhu) who would take the
Mus-haf whilst reciting and hold it against his face whilst crying, saying, “The Book of my Lord! The Book of my Lord!” (2)
Therefore we can say that actions such as this, showing fondness and connection to the
Mus-haf and/or kissing it and all that in the same meaning as the above is permissible and good, but cannot be classified as the
Sunnah as mentioned previously.
Likewise the debate still continues on whether the Qur’ān should ever be placed on the floor especially with many scholars declaring that to be permissible as long as the floor is clean enough to be prayed on. In fact, some weren’t even so stringent, supporting their position with the narration of ‘Atā’ b. Abi Rabāh that a man came to ibn Abbas (
radhy Allāhu ‘anhumā) and said to him, “Can I place the
Mus-haf on a floor that I have intercourse on, that I have wet dreams on and that I sweat all over?” “Yes,” replied ibn ‘Abbās. (3)
It is important to try and restrain emotion in such discussions in order to reach the correct position and many scholars disliked the idea that the Qur’ān be placed on the floor, even extending such dislike to the normal books of religion such as in law or theology for example.
The basis for this was the action of the Prophet (
sallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam) himself as narrated in the hadith of ‘Abdullāh b. ‘Umar (
radhy Allāhu ‘anhumā) when the Prophet (
sallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam) was invited by a Jewish tribe to judge on a Jew who was accused of adultery. When he arrived, they called for a cushion upon which the Prophet (
sallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam) sat upon, whom then asked for the Torah to be brought. When they arrived with it, the Prophet (
sallallāhu ‘alayhi wa sallam) withdrew the cushion from underneath him and placed the Torah upon it and said,
“I have believed in you and the One who sent you,” and the judgement continued. (4)
What this hadith shows other than the supreme conduct of the Messenger of Allah, particularly to non-Muslims, is that there is an understanding of respecting the Holy Books and one such way is to raise them from the ground as one does to other people or precious objects - if this was with the Torah, then what of the Qur’ān?
It is important to note that this does not mean it is an obligation to raise the Qur’ān above the floor rather it is an excellent action of respect; nevertheless one mustn’t accuse the one who doesn’t do it of being an ‘evil person’ who disrespects the Qur’ān, as can be understood above in the
athar of ibn ‘Abbās.
Another example of what is construed as bad
adab is the fact that many Muslims wet their fingers with spittle in order to help them turn the pages of the Qur’ān easier. Many scholars found no problem with such an action, as found in the books of Hanafi and Shāfi‘ī
fiqh. (5)
The Mālikiyyah on the other hand were very strict against such an action, in particular the great ibn ‘Arabi and ibn al-Hāj who almost took the touching of the
Mus-haf with spittle to that of prohibition. (6)
One of the world’s leading
Fuqahā’, Shaykh Muhammad Mukhtar al-Shanqiti, was asked about such a person who wetted his finger to turn a page of the Qur’ān. He replied after explaining that this was something that the people of knowledge differed over..:
“A student of knowledge who believed strongly that this was permissible would argue with my father (who gave a
fatwa instructing people to stay away from such a practice) about this. My father then said, “Ok, fine.” He then placed his finger in his mouth and approaching the face of the student, said, “What do you think if I rub this on your face?” The student took a step back and my father said, “So if this is with you then what of these blessed pages (
al-suhuf al-mukarramah) which have a greater right to be preserved??”
…anyway, these are from the issues concerning honouring the Book of Allah, and it is more complete (in veneration) and excellent to avoid such actions as much as one possibly can.”
This author, in keeping with the series on the Qur’ān with its main objective to increase ones connection to His Words and reflect more upon it and eventually memorise more of His eternal guidance, shall be predominantly keeping to the Māliki school in approach to this subject, not merely out of whim but rather greater experience of that school and their unique skill in the Qur’ān and indeed memorisation as expressed by the inimitable Shanqiti tribe.
There are many ways for the Muslims to rediscover the Qur’ān and realise its intense impact that is stored within. One feels that by allowing the Muslims to feel comfortable and indeed proud of respecting the
adab of the Qur’ān in ways similar to the various permissible
‘urf practices they have grown up with, coupled with a serious and authentic study of its deep meanings via memorisation will be a successful approach, particularly at these times where spiritual veneration is on the wane.
Allah knows best. And with Allah alone is success.
(1) ‘Ulūm’l-Qur’ān, al-Juday’ P. 562 (Mu’assasat’l-Rayyān)
(2) Narrated by al-Dārimi (3228) with an authentic chain, despite many scholars declaring there to be a hidden fault. And Allah knows best.
(3) Narrated by ‘Abd al-Razzāq (1331) on the authority of ibn Jurayj with an authentic chain.
(4) Authentic. Narrated by Abu Dāwūd (4449) with a good chain, via ibn Wahb.
(5) Al-Durr al-Mukhtār (322/1)
(6) ‘Āridhat’l-Ahwadhi (240/10) and al-Madkhal (318/2)