Despite the obvious need for more Muslims to get themselves heard in the ‘West’, particularly to write more for the print media, online-editions of the papers and other news outlets as well as to appear more on TV and the Radio, we have to be ultra careful that it doesn’t backfire – neither on an individual level and more importantly, on a collective level.
A recent email I received was requesting more Muslim bloggers to get involved in the chaotic mess which is “Comment is free” from the online Guardian site – a request not from Muslim bloggers, but non-Muslim bloggers.
It’s hardly surprising though – with the massive interest in anything Islamic, from when we change our undies to brushing our teeth, the greater public are just literally dying to read or hear what we have to say.
Back in the day, we’d be more worried about the different people representing us in the media and bringing shame, humiliation and ignorance upon the Muslim community. Although that still exists to some extent, we have a large pool of people who are well capable of speaking/writing for the Muslims but the danger now is the intrinsic wilful mischief from different sections of the media and their associated forums. You might write something for the Guardian but be prepared to ridiculed over it. Expect your 20 minute interview for Channel M to be cut into two damning sentences. Know that your BBC TV interview will give you no time to say anything, but rather only allow you to answer a closed question.
I think I do my fair share across the range of media that contact me these days and I always believed myself to be savvy to the nuances of journalists and their lies and tricks, but I’ve been stung a few times. Well, actually, more than a few times...
It feels even worse, maybe more so for my naivety, when the journalists are Muslims.
So for now at least, let me warn potential spokespeople of a certain Abul Taher who writes for the Sunday Times – that’s "butter wouldn’t melt in his mouth Abul Taher" – who tried every single trick in the book (legal and illegal I may add) to try and catch me on certain details of the Aisha Azimi niqab story last week – in the end, after a real tug-of-war, he still went ahead and deliberately misquoted me in yesterday’s Sunday Times.
All for his big story. What a petty price my brother, a petty pathetic price.
The details are irrelevant, but the lessons invaluable. Of course we all know the stereotypical yet true nature of the media, not just trash tabloids but the ‘respectable, quality’ sections as well, but that doesn’t mean we still shouldn’t be careful. These people make themselves out to be so sincere and honest but believe me, they can never and must never be trusted. That’s the only reason I write this as no doubt Abul Taher and others read this: do not trust anyone in the media if asked to comment, speak or write about anything to do with Islamic issues.
I’ve started to slowly cut down on such responsibilities, doing much less writing these days but conversely I’ve been reading a bit more and it’s heartening to see that there are eloquent, Islamically educated, astute, well-grounded Muslims out there in the “Islamic Blogosphere” that could represent the Muslims more – people such as Yusuf Smith, Zaid Shakir, Tariq Nelson, Amir Butler, Haroon Moghul, Osama Saeed, Umm Zaid and Riyadh Nadwi just to name a few and of course there are so many more – all doing a noble job and who need to step up to the next level yet it must be with caution for as the opportunities and needs present themselves, so will the dangers.
As long as they remember all the normal golden rules which we often so forget in that pressure situation, and always refer to the people of Knowledge in issues of doubt, then hopefully we can be those who are a credit to the Da'wah and not a evidence against it.
"Our Lord! Make us not a trial for the Disbelievers."
A recent email I received was requesting more Muslim bloggers to get involved in the chaotic mess which is “Comment is free” from the online Guardian site – a request not from Muslim bloggers, but non-Muslim bloggers.
It’s hardly surprising though – with the massive interest in anything Islamic, from when we change our undies to brushing our teeth, the greater public are just literally dying to read or hear what we have to say.
Back in the day, we’d be more worried about the different people representing us in the media and bringing shame, humiliation and ignorance upon the Muslim community. Although that still exists to some extent, we have a large pool of people who are well capable of speaking/writing for the Muslims but the danger now is the intrinsic wilful mischief from different sections of the media and their associated forums. You might write something for the Guardian but be prepared to ridiculed over it. Expect your 20 minute interview for Channel M to be cut into two damning sentences. Know that your BBC TV interview will give you no time to say anything, but rather only allow you to answer a closed question.
I think I do my fair share across the range of media that contact me these days and I always believed myself to be savvy to the nuances of journalists and their lies and tricks, but I’ve been stung a few times. Well, actually, more than a few times...
It feels even worse, maybe more so for my naivety, when the journalists are Muslims.
So for now at least, let me warn potential spokespeople of a certain Abul Taher who writes for the Sunday Times – that’s "butter wouldn’t melt in his mouth Abul Taher" – who tried every single trick in the book (legal and illegal I may add) to try and catch me on certain details of the Aisha Azimi niqab story last week – in the end, after a real tug-of-war, he still went ahead and deliberately misquoted me in yesterday’s Sunday Times.
All for his big story. What a petty price my brother, a petty pathetic price.
The details are irrelevant, but the lessons invaluable. Of course we all know the stereotypical yet true nature of the media, not just trash tabloids but the ‘respectable, quality’ sections as well, but that doesn’t mean we still shouldn’t be careful. These people make themselves out to be so sincere and honest but believe me, they can never and must never be trusted. That’s the only reason I write this as no doubt Abul Taher and others read this: do not trust anyone in the media if asked to comment, speak or write about anything to do with Islamic issues.
I’ve started to slowly cut down on such responsibilities, doing much less writing these days but conversely I’ve been reading a bit more and it’s heartening to see that there are eloquent, Islamically educated, astute, well-grounded Muslims out there in the “Islamic Blogosphere” that could represent the Muslims more – people such as Yusuf Smith, Zaid Shakir, Tariq Nelson, Amir Butler, Haroon Moghul, Osama Saeed, Umm Zaid and Riyadh Nadwi just to name a few and of course there are so many more – all doing a noble job and who need to step up to the next level yet it must be with caution for as the opportunities and needs present themselves, so will the dangers.
As long as they remember all the normal golden rules which we often so forget in that pressure situation, and always refer to the people of Knowledge in issues of doubt, then hopefully we can be those who are a credit to the Da'wah and not a evidence against it.
"Our Lord! Make us not a trial for the Disbelievers."

15 Comments:
salamzzzzzz
too tru!
As-Salaamu 'alaikum,
Flattering as it is to be mentioned next to Imam Zaid Shakir, I myself have had two separate experiences of being skewered by the media.
The first was when I was at college in Wales, and my student union passed a motion to radically reorganise the executive in a way that appeared to give excessive power to the college's noisy, selfish and intransigent Welsh-speaking minority. I wrote the local paper a letter and later spoke to one of their hacks, but when it appeared that I'd got my facts wrong to begin with (although the wording of what they passed actually supports what I said, even if those passing it didn't realise), I asked him not to go ahead with the story because there really wasn't a story. He insisted on going ahead, getting me into some hot water with the union leadership, and managing to misquote me as well.
Then, a few years ago I phoned the Jon Gaunt show which then occupied the morning slot on BBC London (94.9FM) when he said that he did not lose any sleep over Muslim detainees' human rights, in response to a report on the subject by Amnesty International. I said that, in the past, abusive state agencies could justify such behaviour on the grounds that the victims were communists, even if they weren't, and today they use the excuse that they are fundamentalists. He diverted the topic onto the so-called Tipton Taliban, who we now know not to have been Taliban at all, but nonetheless demanded to know if I thought they should be let back into the country. I said yes, because they had gone out to fight the northern alliance (thugs and bandits as we knew many of them were) and were attacked and fought back. He said, "you disgust me" and ended the conversation.
Perhaps a lot of people listening would have shared his sentiments, but I had not called to speculate on the "Tipton Taliban" but about his nonchalant attitude to human rights. I'm not sure if Gaunt is actually smart enough to deliberately manipulate a conversation, unlike some well-known journalists, but still he caught me unawares, because I should have told him that it was not proven that the so-called Tipton Taliban fired a shot at British soldiers, or indeed anyone. (I wrote about my experience on the show here and I've written much more about that bombastic individual on my blog.)
I don't think it's the case that we can't trust all journalists. Most of us are stinkers, but from personal experience, no journalist is going to backstab their mate.
It behoves us all to make more friends in the media, rather than blanket refusing to talk to them. They're going to talk to someone, after all. It should be an incentive to the Muslim community that we become better at dealing with the media, rather than burying our head in the sand.
"They're going to talk to someone, after all. It should be an incentive to the Muslim community that we become better at dealing with the media, rather than burying our head in the sand."
I agree. I've seen too many interviews where muslims don't seem to know what to say. Or just become nervous when the BBC do their, "No time to say anything, but rather only allow you to answer a closed question."
I've been advised that we should get media training before even considering doing any interview or making any comment. Does anyone know how to go about getting media trained?
Crikey. Thanks for the tip, though it's a little late..I got a phonecall from AT last week. I dread to think what he's misquoted from the conversation we had. Where can I find this article?
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
Which article Baji?
Here is an EXCELLENT one......
http://www.as-sahwah.com/viewarticle.php?articleID=1283&
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
I meant the Sunday Times article by Abul Taher. It's okay, he didn't write anything that we talked about, but that's probabaly because I told him to be more original and stop trying to get a dirty scoop of ice-cream on Aisha Azmi :-)
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
TITLE: 6 MILE SPONSORED WALK AROUND PRESTON
ON: SATURDAY 11TH NOVEMBER 2006
AT: 9.00AM
Are you fed up with the bad press that Muslim women are getting at the moment?
'Sisters Striding 4 Children In Need' have organised a six-mile sponsored walk around Preston to raise money for Children In Need and show the positives of the Muslimah for a change.
We need you ALL to get involved and make a POSITIVE CONTRIBUTION TO SOCIETY!
Time is running out so order YOUR SPONSOR PACK NOW!!!
For more information or to register for a sponsor pack please contact:
Aysha Bana 07821041904
Hafizah Ismail 07737602967
Sofia Ali 07760185282
Zeba Desai 07856317221
Closing date to order sponsor packs is 8th November 2006
Children under 12 must be accompanied by an adult
Please do get involved in this worthwhile cause. Thank you!:)
I’ve been contacted by a journalist from the BBC. She emailed me saying she’d like to do a piece on the Niqaab which is positive. I was somewhat weary. I personally don’t trust journalists either. People close to me have had bad experiences with them. And one of my modules at Uni was Media Law – that gave me an insight and a half!
I forwarded her links to some good articles and some things I have written about my experiences. I thought she might not contact me again, because they were generally very positive.
Anyway she rang me today and wanted to ask some questions. I replied that I would prefer to ask her some questions first. What was the focus? How would it be positive?
Here’s the summary,
They want to do something like, ‘A day in the life of a Niqaabi’
They want someone to have a hidden camera attached to a rucksack or handbag.
Just to see people’s reactions to Niqaab.
They want to know how things have been in the light of Jack Straws comments.
How his comments and further comments by other MP’s have affected women who wear the veil?
And how they’ve affected societal relations of those who where the veil.
They also want to do an interview.
I don’t think I will do the camera thing. I don’t see the point or what it will achieve to be honest. It’ll probably capture some streets and cars as I’m pushing Maymoonah in the buggy, talking to her. Then maybe boarding a bus, the usual. Nothing interesting. Maybe a comment or two thrown at me – if it’s a bad day.
As for the interview, I am cautious to say the least. I managed to get her to agree that nothing will be aired until I first see any recording and am happy that it represents my views. I will insist on that being in writing.
For the most part I will mainly have positive things to say. But I had a phone call today from a very upset friend. Her neighborhoods rougher than mine. Full of uneducated scallies throwing abusive comments.
Jack Straws comments opened up the floor for people to be open about their disgusting views.
My husband and I used to share the view that, at least the French are not two faced, they are straightforward and open about their views. While many British people have the same views. They show a pleasing face, open to anything. But what they hide within is dark and ugly prejudice
I’ve changed my mind. From what I heard from my friend today open discrimination is just as dark and ugly. Maybe worse.
I am going to pray Istikharah before making any decision on whether or not to do the interview. I have to say, I have absolutely no experience with anything like this. So any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Please email me at rival120@yahoo.com or you can post on my blog.
This post has been removed by a blog administrator.
Dear respected sisters in Islam (INCLUDING THE 6 MILE WALKERS),
Firstly, may I say that wearing the nikaab is a very brave thing to do in contemporary society. Only, those with strong taqwah would actually wear it. Let's be honest, it's not an easy thing to do, let's give them a voice and support.
Do not be afraid or give it up...
Umm Maymoonah, as far as the BBC is concerned, be very careful. They are the propaganda arm of the government and they may be selective in your comments. Do your Istikhara and follow the guidance to the letter.
Yes, Jack Straw has opened up a can of worms...
He lost face in his constituency in the last local election. He has been demoted from being Foreign Secretary and now he is leader of the commons or something (which is an unimportant post). So he is no longer relying on Muslim votes entirely; he is trying to appeal to the right wingers. I wonder what his agenda will be in the next election; he may even try for labour leadership. That’s why he needs to attract as wider audience as possible.
Also, he’s punishing the Muslim communities, because a lot of Muslims in Blackburn did not vote for him this time due to the war, hence, his new unimportant job, courtesy of the labour leadership.
In Blackburn, once he's used the votes of the right wingers, and regained an important position, he'll dump them, because the indigenous population have many complaints about their living standards within his constituency.
Anyway, may Allah guide and reward all our sisters that wear the Hijab, and especially the ones that wear the hijab and nikaab.
AS FAR AS THE 6 MILE WALK is concerned may Allah grant you all a safe walk, without burden or heckle from the public. Contributing to a secular charity should indeed create doubts among the right wingers, as to their views. May Allah, guide them towards our beloved deen. Ameen.
May Allah protect you all. Ameen.
http://proactivesisters.blogspot.com/
Post a Comment
<< Home